Engaging and frustrating: Lucinda WilliamsReview: Lucinda Williams Venue: Grand Opera House, June 19
Lucinda Williams is a notoriously complex character, her highly-tuned sensitivity infusing her music with a rare, and beautifully-expressed, emotional intelligence. But there’s a downside when she is performing live, as a startled Grand Opera House audience discovered last night.
Halfway through an engaging, and – on occasions – uplifting set, Williams first of all complained about the sound, which was perfect, and then seemed to indicate that she wasn’t getting enough response from the appreciative crowd. In a flash, she had shattered that sacred bond between a live performer and their audience.
What a pity. Williams had started at a cracking pace, with a sublime version of Jackson, featuring some aching beautiful pedal steel guitar from the talented Doug Pettibone, followed up by a superb new song called When I Look At The World and then Copenhagen, the tragic story about love and loss in a cold climate from her 2011 album Blessed.
The sensual Right In Time, delivered in her trademark lustrous drawl, and a coruscating Metal Firecracker, maintained the excellent standard. I felt we were on course for a memorable evening, as she explored her land of broken dreams.
Williams, however, wasn’t happy. She made a public point of changing the set-list, veering towards rock, rather than country, which meant that longed-for classics such as Lake Charles, Car Wheels On A Gravel Road, Passionate Kisses and Sweet Old World remained unplayed, whilst we were treated a blizzard of sound, as she and Pettibone exchanged raucous riffs. The challenging Joy was the low-point of the evening, but the storming Real Live Bleeding Fingers and Guitar Strings illustrated that she had a great rock voice, given the right song.
Thankfully Williams came back for an encore, turning down the volume for a haunting version of Nick Drake’s River Man and the gorgeous Over Time, which she wrote for Willie Nelson. Billed as An Intimate Evening with Lucinda Williams, the intimacy was sadly lost along the way once Williams mistook the audience’s appreciation for indifference.
Support was provided by the charismatic and self-deprecating Jimmy Livingstone, who told us that he was more used to playing “in front of two drunks and a dog”. Maybe that kind of audience would have suited the fragile Lucinda Williams better.
2 Comments
Newest
OldestMost Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Nebraska
9 years ago
Superb performance and I stood up a couple of times-not easy in the dress circle! It was clear that she wasn’t happy and could sense the audience shrinking back-why didn’t she speak to us? Got my husband to shout a couple of requests,but no response.
Had to laugh at her reference to “this moat thing”Quite endearing.
Could have listened to her all night long however.
Lewis
9 years ago
I saw Lucinda Williams at the Royal Festival Hall last November where she was backed by a full band and it was a superb concert, full of intensity, emotion, and interaction with the audience. I felt that last night she was a victim of what some American singer songwriters do when they bring a stripped down approach to a concert. It can result in a reserved, almost reverential response, from the audience which is exactly what Lucinda Williams got last night (and objected to). In turn, she then had to be reassured that everything was alright by a guy appearing on stage – never seen that before! Having said that I thought the last third of her set did contain some of the high points of the set, including ‘Essence’ and ‘Right In Time’, though I thought her interpretation of Joy was just designed to test the audience. Looking on the positive side, after thirty years of going to gigs it was interesting to see that they can still go awry.
We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies.
This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
Superb performance and I stood up a couple of times-not easy in the dress circle! It was clear that she wasn’t happy and could sense the audience shrinking back-why didn’t she speak to us? Got my husband to shout a couple of requests,but no response.
Had to laugh at her reference to “this moat thing”Quite endearing.
Could have listened to her all night long however.
I saw Lucinda Williams at the Royal Festival Hall last November where she was backed by a full band and it was a superb concert, full of intensity, emotion, and interaction with the audience. I felt that last night she was a victim of what some American singer songwriters do when they bring a stripped down approach to a concert. It can result in a reserved, almost reverential response, from the audience which is exactly what Lucinda Williams got last night (and objected to). In turn, she then had to be reassured that everything was alright by a guy appearing on stage – never seen that before! Having said that I thought the last third of her set did contain some of the high points of the set, including ‘Essence’ and ‘Right In Time’, though I thought her interpretation of Joy was just designed to test the audience. Looking on the positive side, after thirty years of going to gigs it was interesting to see that they can still go awry.