• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

News and entertainment worth sharing – York and North Yorkshire

  • News
  • Things to do
  • Radio
  • Vouchers
  • Categories
    • Business
  • More
    • Comments
    • Advertise
    • Contact us
City Cruises York

York pub doomed by council in-fighting – now campaigners demand another vote

Campaigners are calling for a new vote on the future of the Carlton Tavern. Photograph: YorkMix
Sunday 22 October, 2017 @ 8.29 pm Environment, History, Politics YorkMix
Share via...

A York pub has been condemned to demolition – due to an ongoing row within City of York Council.

Members of the council planning committee voted in favour of a plan to demolish the Carlton Tavern and replace it with a modern care home on Wednesday (October 18).

The decision was tied, with committee chairman Cllr Nigel Ayre casting the vote which doomed the pub.

But Cllr Ayre’s appointment as planning chair is shrouded in controversy – to the point where it affected the outcome of the meeting.

Cycle Heaven York
Cycle Heaven York
Cycle Heaven York
Cycle Heaven #ad

‘Totally opposed’

[arve url=”https://youtu.be/ZaBXWLY6m8o” title=”City of York Council planning committee” /]

He was suspended from the council executive in August, along with fellow Liberal Democrat Keith Aspden, while allegations against them were investigated.

Despite this Cllr Ayre was made planning chair earlier this month.

Many found that decision hard to understand, including independent councillor Mark Warters. As a result he is boycotting planning committee meetings until the standards investigation has finished.

That meant he missed Wednesday’s meeting – and he has since confirmed to YorkMix that he would have voted against the Carlton Tavern demolition if he had attended.

Cllr Warters said he is “totally opposed to the loss of yet more of the historic fabric of York and the snatching of local facilities like pubs by developers”.

His vote would have saved the pub.

“However, I won’t be attending any planning committee meetings until such time as this chair business is resolved.”

Veiled threat

Louise Ennis addresses members of the City of York Council Executive. Photograph: YouTube / City of York Council

Partly as a result of this situation, campaigners are calling for another vote on the decision to bulldoze the Carlton, on Acomb Road.

Planners rejected 150 objections when they voted for the care home scheme.

At a meeting of the Executive on Thursday, one of the leading campaigners to save the pub, Louise Ennis told councillors that there were irregularities in the planning committee vote.

She said: “There are concerns that key evidence was missing, misinformation went uncorrected, scrutiny should be applied to the committee composition, process and council speech, and that this affected the ‘finely balanced’ outcome.”

Campaigners are calling for the decision to be annulled. Then, once more evidence has been presented, the full council should vote on the plans.

Local people attend a meeting at the Carlton Tavern to protest against its closure

Louise said: “One hundred and fifty objections to demolition have now been received, including internal consultees, national and local heritage bodies and amenity societies and residents across the city.

“And yet, no detailed working through of options for retaining the asset were provided by the applicant.”

She also raised concerns about the composition of the council, in the light of Cllr Warters’ decision to absent himself and the controvery over Cllr Ayre’s appointment as chair.

And she said: “While being questioned the applicant made a clear point that they had been working with the council and that if the planning permission did not go through they would no longer continue that relationship.

“This veiled threat clearly influenced the decision by members.”

‘Wilful vandalism’

An artist’s impression of the care home planned for the site

The last objection recorded by the council summed up local feeling about the destruction of this Victorian building and the community pub it contains.

“Acomb is OUR village and what you intend to do is little short of an act of wilful vandalism,” Keith Jarvis writes.

“This building is the last remaining Victorian villa of its kind in our community and a focal point that has been part of our lives for many years.

“Retail in Acomb is slowly in decline and to destroy this public amenity would be just another nail in the coffin.

“The Carlton is a meeting place for the local community to use and enjoy time with our families children and grandchildren where the children can play in safety in their own enclosed play area.”

Mr Jarvis adds:

Nowhere else in Acomb provides an amenity like this and to lose it would be a big blow to us.

I don’t suppose that many of you on the planning committee come from this area so its destruction will have no effect on you or your way of life. To our community it means a great deal.

I have lived in Acomb for 74 years and to see this magnificent building reduced to rubble would be heartbreaking.


Related YorkMix stories

Pub campaigners have a backer and a plan – but will councillors save it from demolition?

‘Nothing short of criminal’: Fury at plans to bulldoze landmark York pub

National heritage champion condemns plans to demolish York pub

1 Comment
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
David Ruddock
4 years ago

from what I saw on the meeting, Little notice was taken of any opposition. The Heath Company openly said the Care home would be an Expensive home, so nothing for the City. The Director of Older Persons Accommodation should be removed from office as a total waste of time . Then the Vote. Mr Ayre,s comment was “I do not know which way to vote” and then his vote against instead of calling a Tied Vote gives the impression of a cleverly FIXED Vote.

0

Footer

YorkMix
News 01904 848 766
Email YorkMix news »
5-6 King's Court, Shambles, York  YO1 7LD
YorkMix Radio
General enquiries 01904 375 029
Studio/competitions 01904 375 030
Email YorkMix Radio »
Selby Superbowl, Bawtry Road, Selby  YO8 8NA
YorkMix is a trading name of YorkMix Media Ltd
Registered in England
Company number: 07814727
VAT number: 154 0364 34
© York Sound Ltd

Copyright © 2022 YorkMix Media Ltd

We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies.
Cookie settingsACCEPT
Manage consent

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT
wpDiscuz