• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

News and entertainment worth sharing – York and North Yorkshire

  • News
  • Things to do
  • Radio
  • Vouchers
  • Categories
    • Business
  • More
    • Comments
    • Advertise
    • Contact us
Castle Howard summer concerts 19 - 21 August
Castle Howard summer concerts 19 - 21 August
Castle Howard summer concerts 19 - 21 August
Castle Howard summer concerts 19 - 21 August

York busker plans to use the Magna Carta to stop council evicting him

Wednesday 18 February, 2015 @ 8.38 pm News Chris Titley
Share via...
john-hall-busker
John Hall: home is at risk. Photograph: Richard McDougall

A York busker plans to use the Magna Carta in a last-ditch attempt to prevent the council from evicting him.

John Hall has lived in Sirocco Court, off Fossway, for more than four years. Now he faces homelessness. City of York Council could repossess the property on Thursday (February 19) over claims of unpaid rent and council tax.

But John says he has paid his rent – via promissory notes.

Housing benefit withdrawn

John is often seen playing his guitar in Skeldergate or on Leeman Road. In August he informed the council that he was making some money from his busking.

The council, John said, then stopped his housing benefit. His busking earnings were not enough to cover his rent so he began to pay with promissory notes.

A promissory note is a legally recognised financial document, containing an unconditional promise by the maker to pay a definite sum of money to a payee on demand or at a future date.

John has delivered weekly promissory notes for his rent to the council by fax and by hand.

“They ignored all the promissory notes, didn’t acknowledge them and claimed to have lost them,” he said.

Under the Bills of Exchange Act 1882, he argues, “if someone doesn’t accept your method of payment without good reason then the debt is offset”.

John also says he never received a “proper bill” with a remittance slip on the bottom. He claims the same 1882 Act states that if a creditor does not send a bill the liability is void.

County Court judgement

york-county-court
A legal hearing was held here in January

The council applied to York County Court for a repossession order due to unpaid rent.

John did not turn up for the hearing before District Judge Wildsmith on January 22, but his friend Geoff Beacon put his case.

YorkMix attended the hearing. Here is one of the key exchanges:

Geoff Beacon: “He says he’s paid by promissory notes.”

Judge Wildsmith: “I’d rather have coins of the realm, frankly.”

GB: “I think it’s bizarre but possibly, legally, he’s right. That’s what he claims.”

Judge: “I’m sorry, that’s a load of rubbish. You pay your debt. If you make a promissory note the idea is you have to pay. But he just hasn’t paid it.”

The judge did not grant the council an immediate repossession order but gave John until February 18 to pay his rent arrears plus court costs.

If he doesn’t the council can issue a warrant to repossess the property on Thursday, February 19.

Another court case

John says the council has taken action against him over another bill, council tax, without his knowledge.

Under new legislation, from April 2013 he was liable for ten per cent of his council tax. In September that year he began issuing promissory notes for the amount due, and says under this method he has ‘paid’ up to April 2015.

In January 2014, the council started legal proceedings against him for unpaid council tax. But John says he was never informed, and only found out last December when court staff informed him.

He believes he was deliberately kept in the dark because, as a secure tenant, the council must give him 12 months’ notice to leave.

Turns to the Magna Carta

magna-carta
A1297 copy of Magna Carta, owned by the Australian Government. Photograph © Marcus Wong on Wikimedia Commons
John is fighting the eviction on two grounds:

  • that he has no liability for the rent, because a proper bill was never issued and his promissory notes have not been accepted; and
  • that the council has failed to follow due process of law by seeking a possession order “in secret’.

If that fails he will use an ancient common law route: “lawful rebellion”.

He says this falls under Article 61 of the Magna Carta, the medieval treaty which is celebrating its 800th birthday this year, and is said to enshrine some of our key liberties.

He will appeal to the Queen’s Bench, in an attempt to prove the council is “planning to do him harm” by taking his home.

“I have been on this for six months. It’s extremely stressful,” John said. He added:

I’m anti the ‘new world order’. I wouldn’t risk my home for anything less important.

There were 33 people evicted last year because they couldn’t pay their rent. All those people have now ended up on the street.

If I can succeed, I can help every poor person in England and Wales.

John, who was born in Keighley but came to York as a child and attended Scarcroft School, has lived back in the city for ten years.

Prior to the Salvation Army securing his Sirocco Court home he had lived in a tent and in the Arc Light centre for homeless men.

‘Explore other avenues’

A City of York Council spokesperson said the authority was unable to comment on individual cases. But she added:

However, if a tenant does not pay their rent then officers work with the tenants to explore all the options available to resolve the issue.

If payment is still not forthcoming we have an obligation to ensure that income is recovered. Ultimately we will apply the sanction of eviction, but only after all other avenues have been explored.

Update: Sunday Feb 22

After this post went live, John sent two additional pieces of information. The first is case law regarding promissory notes:

A Lord Denning judgement that says a bill of exchange once tendered has to be treated as cash…

The principle is that a bill, cheque or note is given and taken in payment as so much cash, and not as merely given a right of action for the creditor to litigate a counter claim (see Jackson v Murphy [1887] 4 T.L.R. 92).

“We have repeatedly said in this court that a bill of exchange or a promissory note is to be treated as cash. It is to be honoured unless there is some good reason to the contrary”

– Lord Denning, Fielding & Platt Ltd v Selim Najjar [1969]

John also claims that the council is guilty of “misfeasance in public office” over their rent claim because “as there is no liability there can be no debt”.

This is his definition of misfeasance:

A term used in Tort Law to describe an act that is legal but performed improperly.

Generally, a civil defendant will be liable for misfeasance if the defendant owed a duty of care toward the plaintiff, the defendant breached that duty of care by improperly performing a legal act, and the improper performance resulted in harm to the plaintiff.

 

10 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Geoff Beacon
7 years ago

“The council, John said, then stopped his housing benefit.”

If the council were responsible for John’s housing benefits being stopped how can it claim “officers work with the tenants to explore all the options available to resolve the issue.”?

It would be good to know what role the Council had in benefits being stopped and whether they encouraged him to re-apply.

0
Rebecca Sophia Kim Thompson
7 years ago

The Magna Carta is a most useful tool, I am all for law full rebellion it’s a great piece of legislation good luck John! Please keep us updated on this …😀

0
mania
7 years ago

York council strikes again. Terrorising its people. Makes me sick. They treat people like utter dirt

0
Richard Longstaff
7 years ago

A reet good lad.

0
Andrew G. Whitney
7 years ago

or… he could get a job to support his hobby of busking?!?! It’s ridiculous to think that the costs and grief of an eviction are being incurred by both parties when he is obviously capable… spot on Helen, the immediate need is to reinstate his Housing Benefit, if he qualifies, of course…

0
Lolly Worthington
7 years ago

Plenty of people wouldn’t have bothered admitting to the earnings in the first place and would have continued claiming the housing benefit! Good for him not doing!!

0
Helen Cadbury
7 years ago

It would save more money if they just re-instated his housing benefit.

0
Geoff Beacon
7 years ago

I admit that I don’t fully understand how the law operates in this case and I had actually misunderstood John’s wishes when I put his case. I may comment again after I see John next.

I find it very hard to understand the Council’s statement: “However, if a tenant does not pay their rent then officers work with the tenants to explore all the options available to resolve the issue.”

0
Jo McClure
7 years ago

Be interested to see the outcome of John’s case and his use of the Magna Carta

0
Anton Banks
7 years ago

For god sakes. The tourists love the buskers and it adds to the general ambience of the city

0

Footer

YorkMix
News 01904 848 766
Email YorkMix news »
5-6 King's Court, Shambles, York  YO1 7LD
YorkMix Radio
General enquiries 01904 375 029
Studio/competitions 01904 375 030
Email YorkMix Radio »
Selby Superbowl, Bawtry Road, Selby  YO8 8NA
YorkMix is a trading name of YorkMix Media Ltd
Registered in England
Company number: 07814727
VAT number: 154 0364 34
© York Sound Ltd

Copyright © 2022 YorkMix Media Ltd

We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies.
Cookie settingsACCEPT
Manage consent

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT
wpDiscuz