Here are the full Guildhall ward results, with Labour taking all three and former member of the ruling City of York Council executive Denise Craghill losing out.
Total votes in Guildhall Ward: 8,529.
Guildhall Ward turnout: 32.54%
| Candidate | Elected | Party | Number of votes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Felix Daniel Harris Andrew | No | Liberal Democrats | 172 |
| David William Barratt | No | Conservative | 353 |
| Tony Clarke | Yes | Labour | 1,593 |
| Denise Craghill | No | Green | 901 |
| Matthew Graham Freckelton | No | Conservative | 323 |
| Brandon Masih | No | Liberal Democrats | 134 |
| Rachel Kate Melly | Yes | Labour | 1,707 |
| Dave Merrett | Yes | Labour | 1,501 |
| Henry James Stevens | No | Green | 677 |
| Martina Weitsch | No | Green | 716 |
| Geoffrey John Widdows | No | Conservative | 320 |
| Scarlett Roberta Wighton | No | Liberal Democrats | 132 |